Clients often approach BSLC after receiving an insurance payment that they feel falls far short of their rights. For example, following a road accident, a car owner receives BGN 3,200 for property damage while actual repair quotations exceed BGN 6,000. The insurer relies on an internal assessment method, depreciation or a policy limit. The client is left wondering whether the payment is final or can be challenged.
This question has direct legal significance. Insurance payments are often genuinely too low, and the law provides remedies. The main risk is that a failure to respond promptly and correctly may deprive the insured of the opportunity to recover compensation for the full loss.
BSLC assists with the following matters.
- Low payments under comprehensive motor insurance, known as Casco, or motor third-party liability insurance
- Disputes with insurers over damage valuations
- Preparation of claims for additional compensation
- Court proceedings against insurers
- Proving the actual extent of property damage ⚖️
Can a low insurance payment be challenged under Bulgarian law?
Yes. The law expressly protects this right.
The Bulgarian Insurance Code, known as KZ, is the special legislation governing the matter. It is functionally equivalent to insurance legislation in other European countries, such as Germany's Versicherungsvertragsgesetz. The fundamental principle is that the insurer owes compensation corresponding to the loss actually suffered.
Article 386(2) KZ expressly provides that, in property insurance, compensation must equal the actual damage at the time of the event. This fundamental rule restricts insurers from paying arbitrarily reduced amounts.
Several important conclusions follow.
- An insurer cannot assess compensation using internal rules that conflict with the law.
- A payment is not final if it fails to cover the actual loss.
- The insured may claim the difference up to the full amount of the damage.
Common reasons for undervaluation include excessive depreciation, unrealistically low prices for parts or labour, disregarding actual reinstatement costs and recognising only part of the damage.
Under Article 386(1) KZ, the sum insured is the maximum limit of liability, not an amount automatically payable. If the loss exceeds the payment but remains below that limit, the difference can be claimed.
A challenge may be made outside court through an objection and an additional claim, or through proceedings against the insurer.
How can a higher amount of loss be proved?
Evidence is central to any dispute with an insurance company. The law requires compensation to reflect actual damage, but the insured must establish it.
Insurance compensation represents the monetary value of the damage, including expenses incurred to limit the consequences of the event. Evidence may therefore cover more than the repair itself.
The main types of evidence used are the following.
- Expert assessments in automotive, construction or other technical fields
- Repair invoices and quotations
- Photographs and inspection reports
- Witness testimony in appropriate cases
- Documents from repair workshops or suppliers
The most significant evidence in court is usually a court-appointed expert opinion. The court appoints an expert to determine the actual loss independently. This often results in a substantial increase in compensation.
Do not rely exclusively on the insurer's valuation. Collect evidence from the moment the damage occurs, request a written explanation of the calculation and consult an insurance disputes lawyer where the loss is substantial.
A frequent mistake is to treat the initial payment as final. It may in fact constitute only partial performance of the insurer's obligation.
What does a court claim against an insurer involve?
If attempts at an out-of-court resolution fail, the next step is litigation.
The right of action arises from the insurance contract and the general rules of obligations law. The insured, or the injured third party in liability insurance, may claim the unpaid portion of the compensation.
The claim usually includes the following amounts.
- The principal, representing the difference between the compensation due and the amount paid
- Statutory late-payment interest after the statutory payment period expires, under Article 409 KZ
- Litigation costs
The case follows civil procedure. The court establishes whether an insured event occurred, checks policy cover, determines the actual loss through expert evidence and compares it with the amount already paid.
The court is not bound by the insurer's valuation. It assesses the evidence independently.
Certain specific rules also matter. Under liability insurance, the injured party has a direct action against the insurer. Where compensation has been paid in part, only the outstanding difference can be pursued. Limitation periods are finite, and missing them results in a loss of rights.
Underestimating the proceedings is a practical risk. Even a well-founded claim can fail without a correctly formulated demand and an evidence strategy.
Professional legal assistance with an insurance dispute is therefore essential to calculate the claim properly and present it effectively in court. The legal fees calculator can help with an initial estimate of costs.
A low insurance payment is often the starting point for protecting the insured's rights. The law requires full compensation for the loss. Where this has not been provided, a challenge to the insurance company may be entirely justified and legally supportable.

.webp)






