Clients often ask us whether they can obtain Act 16 if their developer has stopped building or run out of money. Behind that question usually lies much more than a delayed document. One buyer has paid almost the entire price but still has no title deed. Another already owns the apartment but cannot move in. A third is willing to contribute towards completion, provided they understand their rights and whether the next payment will actually bring the building closer to lawful use.
A building can be completed and approved for use without the original contractor. The solution, however, involves more than finding another firm to continue the work. It is necessary to establish who owns the unfinished units, who is entitled to commission the remaining construction, which records have been prepared and exactly what is preventing acceptance. If the seller is in insolvency proceedings or the properties are mortgaged, the insolvency administrator, the court and the secured creditors also become part of the picture.
The buyer's most important choice often needs to be made before discussions about a new budget begin. Should you insist on receiving the promised apartment, or terminate the agreement and ask for your money back? Knowing that the building is “at Act 14” or “at Act 15” is not enough to answer that question properly. The construction stage must be considered alongside the particular agreement and the rights actually acquired.
That connection explains why two buyers in the same building may need different legal protection. In this article, we examine new residential buildings in Bulgaria, explaining what each main stage means, which possibilities it opens up and how the building can progress towards Act 16 when the developer suffers a financial collapse.
What should you establish first when building work stops?
The first question is which company is actually failing to meet its obligations. In everyday conversation, “the developer” usually means the company whose name appears in the advertising. In the documents, however, the apartment seller, the construction client and the contractor carrying out the work may be different parties. This determines whom the buyer has a claim against and whose financial problems put their ownership at risk.
The seller under the preliminary agreement undertakes to transfer the promised right. Whether it also owes an obligation to build, complete the property or secure approval for use depends on the agreement's terms. The construction client is the party with the legal right to undertake the project, usually the landowner or the holder of an established right to build. This is the status defined by Article 161 of the Spatial Development Act, referred to below by its Bulgarian abbreviation ZUT. The contractor carries out the commissioned work. Acting as the contractor does not, by itself, make that company the owner of the apartments.
If the difficulties affect only the contractor, the construction client can arrange to end that relationship and organise completion with another firm. If the seller enters insolvency while still owning the promised properties, the task is different. The buyer must also protect the possibility of acquiring the apartment or recovering the money paid, while the seller's creditors seek payment from its assets.
A construction stoppage and the opening of insolvency proceedings are not the same thing. The company may have a temporary shortage of funds, may have stopped work without any court proceedings, or may already be subject to the special insolvency regime. Court decisions and entries in the Commercial Register show whether proceedings have been opened and how they are progressing. Whether the financial difficulties are temporary and construction can realistically resume must also be assessed against the company's actual performance, liabilities and available assets. Ownership, mortgages and registered attachments must be checked as well. A manager's promise that “we will restart soon” does not alter other parties' registered rights.
A lack of funds does not, by itself, release a debtor from liability, as Article 81(2) of the Obligations and Contracts Act, referred to below as ZZD, expressly provides. The practical problem is different. Even a well-founded claim must be recoverable from available assets. The legal assessment therefore considers both what is owed under the agreement and the realistic prospects of acquiring the property, completing it or recovering the payments.
What do Act 14, Act 15 and Act 16 mean for an apartment buyer?
When construction is progressing normally, these labels are often treated as successive payment dates. A stoppage reveals why their meaning matters. A building's physical progress is one question. Whether that progress has been duly established is another. Which transactions can be entered into for the constructed property, and whether it may already be occupied, are separate questions again.
Do the rough construction stage and Act 14 mean the same thing?
The rough construction stage is, first and foremost, a physical state of the building. It is reached when the enclosing walls and roof have been completed, while finishing work may be absent or completed to varying degrees. This is the meaning of the definition in § 5, item 46 of the supplementary provisions of ZUT. In other words, the rough construction stage results from the actual completion of the necessary work, rather than the signing of a document.
Act 14 has a different immediate purpose. It records acceptance of the load-bearing structure. For an ordinary apartment block, the contractor, the structural designer and the relevant specialist within the construction supervision team assess the work against the structural design, earlier records, tests and documentation for the products used. They conclude whether the structure can be accepted in compliance with the legal requirements. The procedure is governed by Article 7(3), item 14 of Ordinance No. 3 on records and protocols during construction.
The two events may occur close together, but they should not be treated as identical. For example, a reinforced concrete structure may be complete while the specified non-load-bearing enclosing walls have yet to be built. Acceptance of the structure does not then establish, by itself, that every element of the rough construction stage is in place. This distinction follows from the opinion of the National Construction Control Directorate, known as DNSK, dated 26 August 2025 and endorsed by the Ministry of Regional Development and Public Works on 20 October 2025.
The practical consequence for the buyer is quite specific. If an instalment or the final sale is linked to “Act 14”, the parties' precise agreement must be established. Did they mean signing the structural acceptance record, physically reaching the rough construction stage, or also producing the administration's certification of that stage? These expressions should not be used interchangeably, especially where a substantial part of the price depends on them.
Why does the rough construction stage also need to be certified after Act 14?
For the stage reached to be relied on when preparing a notarised property transaction, it must be established through the prescribed procedure. Act 14 forms an important part of the supporting documentation. It is submitted together with the documents establishing ownership or the right to build, the building permit and the other relevant construction documents. The record is therefore more than an internal document between the construction participants. It also supports the issue of the certificate confirming that the rough construction stage has been reached.
The stage reached is also established through the administrative procedure provided for that purpose. Article 181(3) ZUT provides for a protocol recording completion to the rough construction stage. Transitional provision § 87 of the 2021 amendment preserves the previous procedure until the relevant form is approved. Under that continuing procedure, the municipal or district administration establishes the stage reached. Municipalities provide this certification as a service for issuing protocols and certificates concerning the degree of completion. In practice, the document produced for the transaction is commonly known as an “Article 181 ZUT certificate”. The official description of the administrative service for Studentski District expressly lists Act 14 among the documents on which the certificate is based.
The underlying event must be distinguished from its proof. A building is at the rough construction stage because the relevant work has been completed. The certificate establishes that fact for the purposes of legal transactions. Neither signing Act 14 nor issuing the certificate can replace missing enclosing walls or a roof. If the record or certificate is prepared later, its date should not automatically be treated as the date of physical completion. Conversely, a structure and walls visible on inspection do not relieve the notary of checking which right is being transferred and in which property.
The certificate is the usual documentary route for this check, but it is not the only admissible evidence that the rough construction stage has actually been reached. In Decision No. 22 of 4 June 2020 in Civil Case No. 3048/2019, Second Civil Division, the Supreme Court of Cassation also considers establishing the stage through expert evidence in notarial proceedings under Article 533 of the Civil Procedure Code, referred to below as GPK. In a court dispute, physical completion may be proved by all admissible forms of evidence. This is a matter for assessment in the relevant proceedings. It does not allow a buyer to replace the construction documents unilaterally with a privately commissioned opinion.
This also explains why, on a stalled project, the lawyer checks more than whether a document bearing a particular title has been produced. It matters which building or authorised stage it concerns and exactly what it certifies. A discrepancy between the construction documents, the work actually completed and the description of the apartment being sold can obstruct both the transfer and mortgage finance.
Does Act 15 mean that the building is fully finished?
At Act 15, the question is no longer simply whether the structure has been completed. The assessment concerns whether the construction is fit for acceptance in accordance with the approved designs, permissible amendments, construction documents and requirements governing the work. The construction client, designers, contractor and construction supervisor participate in establishing that condition, and the contractor hands the building and its documentation over to the client. This is the purpose of the record under Article 176(1) ZUT.
Fitted windows and plastered walls are not enough on their own. The specified work must support a positive assessment of the building's readiness for acceptance, including its common areas, installations and safety. A well-finished apartment, for example, does not compensate for a missing safe staircase or an unfinished shared electrical installation. The assessment covers the construction within its authorised scope, rather than merely the interior of one home.
Equally, Act 15 does not necessarily mean a fully finished apartment. If the approved design and agreement provide for handover with plastered walls and screeded floors, acceptance of the building does not itself require the contractor to install flooring or furnishings that were never agreed. The reverse is also true. If the seller expressly promised a higher standard of finish, signing Act 15 does not release it from that obligation. In other words, the readiness required for administrative purposes and the performance owed to a particular buyer must be considered together, but they are not the same thing.
The record may identify outstanding work and defects. These must be remedied, and that must be documented before the application for approval for use is submitted. The statement “we have Act 15, only Act 16 remains” is therefore reliable only after the record and its attachments have been read. Sometimes all that remains is to assemble the administrative file. In another case, the document itself shows that further work, money and time are still required.
Why do the other construction records matter too?
Acts 14 and 15 rely on the documentation of the construction work that preceded them. The protocol opening the site and establishing the building line and level records the commencement and positioning of the construction. Acceptance records for individual structural elements trace their execution, while records of concealed work establish what can no longer be directly inspected after it is covered. Later acceptance is thus based on verifiable information, rather than solely on the building's visible condition.
When work continues with a new contractor, records of the condition at suspension and of the resumption of construction are particularly important too. We examine them below. The document commonly called “Act 19”, however, usually records quantities, prices and payment for work completed. It is not a further administrative stage after Act 16 and does not replace acceptance or a use permit.
BSLC · Legal analysis · Bulgaria
How do rough construction, Act 14 and a mortgage relate in Bulgaria?
A property transaction depends on what has been built, the evidence of its condition and the rights over the property. These are connected, but each has a distinct legal role.
When has the building reached rough construction?
Rough construction is a physical stage at which the enclosing walls and roof have been completed. It is achieved through building work. Documents establish that fact rather than create it.
What is accepted under Act 14?
Act 14 records acceptance of the load-bearing structure. This may precede completion of all the elements required for rough construction. Acceptance of the structure and completed rough construction are therefore different matters.
How is the stage officially established?
Under the retained transitional procedure, the municipal or district administration establishes completion of rough construction. Act 14 forms part of the supporting records. The administrative service is commonly described as issuing a rough construction certificate.
What allows the apartment to be sold or mortgaged?
Reaching rough construction allows the constructed unit itself to be the subject of the transaction. The stage and ownership must be proved. A contractual mortgage requires a notarial deed and takes effect upon registration, not upon certification of construction.
Before rough construction, the holder of an established right to build may mortgage that right. Certification does not guarantee a bank loan or authorise occupation. Act 15 does not authorise use either. Categories one to three require a use permit following Protocol 16, while categories four and five require a commissioning certificate.
When is Act 16 required, and can you live in the building without it?
A new residential building must be approved for use before it is occupied as a home. This requirement does not disappear because the buyer has a title deed, has received the keys, has furnished the apartment or is using electricity and water. Ownership gives the buyer rights over the property, but does not remove the administrative conditions for using the new building for its intended purpose. Article 178 ZUT prohibits use before the required approval.
It is also necessary to clarify what “Act 16” means. For construction categories I, II and III, a State Acceptance Commission prepares a Form 16 protocol. On that basis, the competent authority within DNSK issues a separate use permit. The protocol itself records the inspection findings and the commission's recommendation. Lawful use depends on the subsequent permit, rather than merely on collecting signatures on the protocol.
For categories IV and V, the procedure ends with a commissioning certificate issued by the authority that granted the building permit. These categories do not require the same State Acceptance Commission or a Form 16 protocol under the procedure for categories I to III. In everyday language, however, both the use permit and the certificate are called “Act 16”. The distinction matters because it determines which authority receives the application and which procedure it follows. The rules are set out in Article 177(2) and (3) ZUT.
For ordinary residential buildings, low-rise construction up to 10 metres is generally category V, construction over 10 and up to 15 metres is category IV, and construction over 15 metres is category III. These are height criteria under ZUT, rather than an informal classification based on the number of storeys advertised. If a project has characteristics falling within more than one category, the higher category applies. The assessment for a particular building must therefore begin with its construction documents and the criteria in Article 137 ZUT.
The exceptions are specific. Category VI works and changes of use without building work under Article 147a ZUT do not undergo commissioning through the general procedure. That does not exempt a new apartment block or detached house. A small low-rise house is generally category V, while category VI covers other expressly specified works, such as certain small swimming pools and retaining walls. For the buyer of such a new home, the consequence is clear. Whether the building is a large block or a small house, lawful occupation requires the final approval applicable to its category.
Unlawful occupation can lead to a prohibition on use, an order to vacate the building and disconnection of utilities. For categories I to III, the relevant powers lie with the competent DNSK authority. For categories IV and V, they lie with the municipality's mayor or an authorised municipal officer. The fact that other owners have already moved in creates no exception to these rules.
Commissioning matters for more than avoiding these consequences. It allows the home to be used lawfully for its intended purpose and confirms that the administrative procedure assessing the building's readiness has been completed. This usually assists a later sale or bank financing because the risk associated with an unfinished approval procedure is removed. It does not, however, cancel a mortgage, resolve an ownership dispute or release the contractor from liability for defects.
Can you acquire and mortgage the apartment before Act 16?
What does it mean that separate units exist after the rough construction stage?
Before it is built, a future home may be described in detail in the design and preliminary agreement, but that is not the same as an existing apartment constituting a separate immovable property. Once the rough construction stage is reached, there is a constructed building whose designated individual units can be transferred. Article 181 ZUT governs this change in the subject of the transaction. Until the rough construction stage, the established right to build can be transferred. After that stage, the constructed building or separate parts of it can be transferred.
In other words, a buyer purchasing an apartment after that stage acquires the existing unit itself, even though it is not yet ready for occupation. The buyer need not wait for Act 16 for such a sale to be possible. The apartment must, however, constitute a legally permissible separate unit, be sufficiently identified, and belong to the seller in terms of the right being transferred. Certification of the rough construction stage does not replace those checks.
For an ordinary multi-storey building, casting the slab above the selected apartment is not enough if the rest of the building has not reached the required stage. Exercise of the right to build depends on the rough construction stage of the whole building or a duly authorised independent stage. This is explained in Interpretative Decision No. 1 of 4 May 2012 in Interpretative Case No. 1/2011 of the Supreme Court of Cassation. An apartment identified separately in the design and an independent construction stage are different concepts.
A cadastral plan identifies the unit but does not, by itself, create ownership. The same is true of Act 14 and the rough construction certificate. Ownership is established from rights over the land, the right to build and the transactions entered into. If a buyer has already acquired a right to build a particular unit, reaching the rough construction stage matters for the exercise of that right and acquisition of the constructed property. If the buyer has only a preliminary agreement, construction progress alone does not make them the owner.
Why does the rough construction certificate matter for a mortgage?
If the constructed apartment itself is to secure the loan, the bank and notary must establish that it already exists as a property capable of being mortgaged. This is where the sequence of physical construction, Act 14 and certification under Article 181 ZUT becomes important. Acceptance of the structure and the other construction records help establish that the rough construction stage has been reached. The certificate for that stage then forms part of the documentary basis for proceeding with a notarised sale and a mortgage over the constructed unit.
That does not mean that the certificate itself creates the mortgage. A contractual mortgage requires an agreement in notarial form, and the mortgage right arises through registration on the basis of that agreement. The property must be identified and belong to the person mortgaging it. This follows from Articles 166 and 167 ZZD. The certificate therefore proves the construction stage, the title documents establish the right of the person granting the mortgage, and the notarial deed and registration create the security itself.
For example, when an apartment at the rough construction stage is purchased with a bank loan, certification of the stage allows the transaction to be prepared for the already constructed unit. The buyer acquires ownership through the notarised sale and can then grant the agreed mortgage over the acquired property. Registration creates the bank's security, while disbursement follows the loan agreement's conditions. Each document and each step therefore has a distinct role that cannot be fulfilled merely by producing Act 14.
This should not be taken to mean that no mortgage is possible before Act 14. An established and transferable right to build can also be mortgaged before it is exercised through completion to the rough construction stage. Mortgages over land with agreed effects on future construction are also possible. Their consequences must be assessed against the mortgage deed and the rights over the property. A check for encumbrances must therefore examine not only entries relating to the already constructed apartment, but also earlier rights over the land and the right to build.
Whether a mortgage is legally possible and whether a loan is approved are separate questions. A bank may require a particular construction stage, a valuation, proof of income, conditions for release from an earlier mortgage and a specific disbursement procedure. The rough construction certificate allows that stage to be proved, but does not oblige the bank to finance the purchase. Where construction has stopped, the funding conditions must be coordinated with the practical ability to acquire and complete the property.
What do you hold if you have paid the price but have only a preliminary agreement?
A preliminary agreement creates a right to demand conclusion of the promised final transaction under the agreed and statutory conditions. It does not transfer ownership, even if the price has been paid in full and the apartment already exists at the rough construction stage. An ordinary sale transfers ownership through an agreement in notarial form. If the seller refuses to proceed, a court judgment can replace the final transaction where the requirements discussed in the next section are met.
Consider two buyers in the same building. The first has already acquired the apartment by notarial deed after certification of the rough construction stage. The second has paid the same amount, but their agreement provides for transfer after commissioning. If the seller encounters financial difficulties, the first buyer must protect the property already acquired and organise the completion work owed. The second must still decide how to obtain ownership or seek repayment. The terms and performance of the agreements, rather than merely the number of the latest construction record, determine the next step.
What can you do if you have paid but do not yet have a title deed?
For a buyer holding a preliminary agreement, the central question is whether the promised property can still be acquired or whether legal action should focus on recovering the money. These are not interchangeable courses of action. A claim for the final sale requires the agreement to remain in force, while valid termination removes the basis for demanding that sale. In other words, the buyer needs to decide what outcome to pursue before sending the first notice.
Payment alone does not transfer the promised property right, even if it covers the entire price. It proves that the payment obligation has been performed and matters for claims against the seller. If the apartment still belongs to the seller, however, it remains exposed to action by the seller's creditors. Where completion is realistically possible, acquiring the property may therefore be a better solution than a repayment claim against a company with no unencumbered assets.
This assessment begins with the preliminary agreement, its amendments and the payments made. The construction deadline, the deadline for commissioning and the date for the notarised sale must be distinguished. They may coincide, but are often dealt with separately. If the contractor is late completing the building, that does not necessarily mean the agreed time for transferring ownership has also arrived. An oral promise of Act 16 “in a few weeks” does not, by itself, change the deadlines agreed in writing either.
When can you ask a court to make you the owner?
If the seller is already obliged to complete the final sale but refuses or takes no action, the buyer can seek a judgment that takes its place. This requires a claim to have the preliminary agreement declared final under Article 19(3) ZZD. If the claim succeeds, the agreement is deemed concluded when the judgment becomes final. It is the judgment, rather than the earlier payment, that effects the promised transfer.
A successful claim requires a valid and continuing written preliminary agreement containing the essential terms, including a sufficiently identified property and price. The transfer obligation must have fallen due, and the seller must hold the promised right in a property that can lawfully be the subject of the transaction. The court also checks the requirements that a notary would examine under Article 363 of the Civil Procedure Code (GPK). It cannot transfer someone else's apartment merely because the buyer paid in good faith, nor substitute a different property at its own discretion.
This is where the distinction between the rough construction stage and Act 16 matters. If the final agreement is due at the duly established rough construction stage and the time for the sale has arrived, the absence of permission to occupy does not, by itself, prevent acquisition through the court. The buyer can become the owner of an unfinished apartment and then pursue performance of the remaining construction obligations. Acquiring ownership does not, however, complete the building or authorise its use.
The position is different where transfer is agreed for after Act 16. The legal possibility of selling an apartment earlier does not mean that the seller promised to transfer it earlier. The whole clause must be read, including whether it contains a final calendar deadline, how that deadline relates to the administrative approval and who undertook to obtain the approval. An agreement setting an independent final date for the notarised sale, for example, is not assessed in the same way as one linking the sale solely to a future construction stage. The seller's financial difficulties do not automatically accelerate every future obligation.
A deadline for performance must also be distinguished from the duration of the agreement. The passing of the agreed date for the final sale does not, by itself, mean that the promise to sell has automatically expired. It usually means that the sale is overdue and performance can be pursued. A different result may follow from a particular termination clause or a valid termination that has already taken effect.
An unpaid balance is not necessarily an insurmountable obstacle either. The court can declare the agreement final on condition that the buyer performs the reciprocal obligation within two weeks after the judgment becomes final. If the buyer does not pay, the defendant can ask for the judgment to be set aside. In Interpretative Decision No. 4/2020 of 9 May 2023, the Supreme Court of Cassation held that this procedure under Article 362 GPK is also available where the parties agreed to conclude the final agreement only after payment of the entire price. That ruling does not remove the other requirements for the claim or override every separate condition concerning a future Act 16.
The order and timing of the protective steps are also important. Subject to the statutory conditions, registration of the statement of claim prevents rights acquired by third parties after registration from being asserted against the buyer who wins the case. It does not make the buyer the owner upon filing, and it does not remove earlier mortgages. After a successful claim, the final judgment must be noted in the property register within the six-month period under Article 115 of the Property Act to preserve the effect of the original registration.
When can you terminate the preliminary agreement and seek repayment?
If ending the purchase is the realistic way forward, the first task is to identify which substantial obligation remains unperformed and why the seller is responsible. Delay in the agreed construction work may constitute such non-performance, but a rumour of impending insolvency is not enough on its own. The buyer must also have met their own obligations that have fallen due or have a lawful basis for withholding performance. Non-performance that is insignificant in relation to the buyer's interest does not justify terminating the whole agreement under Article 87(4) ZZD.
A preliminary agreement can generally be terminated without court proceedings because it does not itself transfer property rights. For a written agreement, the usual procedure is a written warning that reaches the seller and allows an appropriate additional period for performance. The warning must state clearly that the agreement will be treated as terminated when that period expires. A notice served through a notary helps prove its contents and delivery, but is not universally mandatory. This is the mechanism under Article 87(1) ZZD.
No additional period is required in the three situations under Article 87(2) ZZD. The first is where performance has become wholly or partly impossible. The second is where delay has made performance useless to the creditor. The third is where performance had to take place at the precise time agreed. A date in the agreement does not, by itself, establish the third situation. It must be shown that performance at that particular time was essential to the contractual interest, rather than merely that an ordinary delay has occurred.
Under a separate construction contract, it is not always necessary to wait until the final deadline. If it is already clear that the contractor will not perform on time or in the agreed manner, the construction client has the protection provided by Article 262(2) ZZD. Where an agreement combines a future sale with construction obligations, however, the relationship between those two parts must be established. Ending the construction engagement should not inadvertently remove the intended route to acquiring the apartment.
The practical meaning of termination also matters. It removes the contractual basis for retaining the payments and opens the way to claim them back, but does not automatically return money to the buyer's account. If the seller does not pay voluntarily, the claim must be established and recovered through legal proceedings. Where insolvency proceedings have opened, their special rules apply. Interest, contractual penalties and damages each have their own legal basis and must be assessed against the agreement, the delay and the losses proved.
Imagine a buyer who wants to keep the apartment but sends a notice terminating the agreement and demanding repayment of the price. If termination takes effect, that agreement can no longer be declared final by the court. The opposite mistake is to keep an agreement alive when there is no realistic route to performance, while deadlines for legal protection expire. The first letter is therefore more than a formality. It expresses the legal outcome the buyer has chosen to pursue.
An advance payment must also be distinguished from an earnest deposit. The colloquial Bulgarian label “kaparo” does not mean that twice the amount is necessarily repayable. That may be possible under Article 93 ZZD where the payment genuinely serves as an earnest deposit, the recipient defaults and the party that has met its obligations withdraws from the agreement on that basis. An ordinary advance is simply part of the price paid in advance. It does not double merely because construction has stopped.
Can you stop further instalments before losing more money?
The answer depends on what the particular instalment is payable for and when it falls due. If the agreement requires payment after a certain stage and that stage has not been reached, the first question is whether any payment obligation has become due at all. This differs from a situation in which the instalment is already due but the buyer relies on a right to withhold performance.
If a reciprocal obligation under the same legal relationship is due and unperformed, the buyer may withhold their own performance under Article 90 ZZD. The law also provides protection where the circumstances make it clear that there is a risk of the other party failing to perform. In that second situation, performance may be withheld unless adequate security is provided. In other words, existing non-performance and a clear risk of future non-performance are different grounds that must be supported by specific facts.
Stopping all transfers solely on the strength of something a neighbour has said is therefore risky. The contractual stages, due dates, actual performance and available evidence must be considered together. Otherwise, an apparently protective step may give the seller grounds to allege that the buyer is in default.
How can you preserve assets from which your claim could be paid?
Where there is a risk that properties will be sold or available funds will disappear, the court can grant interim protection for the claim. For a monetary claim, an appropriate measure may be an attachment of bank accounts or receivables, or a registered attachment over immovable property. The aim is to prevent a future judgment from becoming worthless in practice because there are no assets against which it can be enforced.
A bare allegation that the developer is unreliable is not enough. The court assesses the apparent merits of the claim and the risk that enforcing the right will become impossible or more difficult. It may require the applicant to provide security. Interim protection is possible before the main proceedings begin, but the claim must then be filed within the deadline set by the court, which cannot exceed one month. The procedure is governed by Article 389 and the following provisions of GPK.
Attachments do not provide the same security as a mortgage or confer a mortgage creditor's priority. They do not remove earlier encumbrances or guarantee that the assets will cover every creditor's claim. This is why encumbrances must be checked before deciding whether a repayment claim will also be recoverable in practice.
BSLC · Legal analysis · Bulgaria
What can you do with the documents you hold?
Buyers in the same building may have paid the same amount but need different legal protection.
- Do you hold only a preliminary agreement?
- Payment does not make you the owner. If the seller owns the unit and transfer is already due, acquisition through a court judgment may be available. If termination takes effect, the basis for claiming the property falls away, while recovery of the money remains a separate step.
- Do you already own the apartment?
- Ownership already acquired and the right to have construction completed are distinct rights. The seller’s insolvency does not automatically return the apartment to its assets. An earlier mortgage may nevertheless allow the apartment to be sold to satisfy the secured debt, even after Act 16.
- Have insolvency proceedings opened?
- A monetary claim must be submitted to the court within the special deadlines. Admission of the claim does not guarantee payment, because recovery depends on available assets and creditors’ ranking. Completion arrangements must also respect the powers of the insolvency administrator and the court.
Insolvency can affect both groups of buyers. Lodging a monetary claim does not replace protection of ownership already acquired.
What are your options if you already own the apartment?
Once ownership has been acquired, the task is no longer to obtain a judgment replacing the promised sale, but to preserve the property and secure the completion work owed. The seller's insolvency does not automatically return a duly transferred apartment to its assets. The acquisition must nevertheless be examined alongside earlier registered rights and the statutory grounds on which the particular transaction might be challenged.
Why can the developer's mortgage put an apartment you have already bought at risk?
A mortgage follows the encumbered property when ownership changes. This means that a buyer may have paid the entire price and hold a title deed, yet the bank may still be entitled to enforce against the apartment for an unpaid secured debt of the previous owner. The legal basis is Article 173 ZZD. The buyer does not automatically become personally liable for the whole loan, but the property acquired may still be used to satisfy the creditor.
For example, paying the price into the developer's account does not prove that it has repaid the relevant portion of its bank loan and released the apartment. There must be specific release terms from the mortgage creditor for that unit, fulfilment of those terms and proper cancellation of the mortgage. Act 16 replaces none of these steps. Otherwise, owners may fund completion of a building while their apartments remain exposed to a forced sale.
If the original mortgage covered the land or the right to build, its description alone cannot establish that the future apartments are free of encumbrances. Its scope depends on the mortgage deed, the parties holding the relevant rights and the sequence of acquisitions and construction. An assurance that the mortgage is “only over the land” does not replace that examination.
Does transferring ownership release the seller from its obligation to complete the building?
Not necessarily. The final agreement fulfils the transfer obligation, but does not, by itself, extinguish a separate undertaking to finish the work or secure commissioning. The final agreement, preliminary agreement, amendments and any separate construction contract need to be read together. They establish which promises remain binding after the sale and against whom claims can be brought.
Where an obligation is due but unperformed, the creditor may demand performance together with damages for delay, or damages in place of performance under Article 79 ZZD. If someone else can carry out the work, Article 80 ZZD allows the creditor to seek permission for that to be done at the debtor's expense. The law thus allows the missing performance to be provided by someone else. It does not grant unrestricted access to another person's property or turn every sum paid unilaterally into an automatically recoverable debt owed by the original contractor.
Work that has not been done must be distinguished from work that is defective. If the roof has not been finished at all, the dispute concerns non-performance. If it has been built but leaks because of a defect, the construction client has the remedies under Article 265 ZZD. These include repair within an appropriate period at no additional charge, the necessary repair costs or a reduction in the contract price. Termination is available where departures or defects are so substantial that the work is unfit for its agreed or ordinary purpose.
Before a new contractor remedies the defect, its condition must be documented. After repair, it may be difficult to prove exactly what was done incorrectly. Where a dispute is expected, a court procedure to preserve evidence may therefore be appropriate. Objections to defects discoverable on an ordinary inspection must be raised upon acceptance. Hidden defects, or those appearing later, must be reported to the contractor immediately after discovery, unless the contractor already knew of them. This is the distinction drawn by Article 264 ZZD.
For construction work, the rights under Article 265 are subject to a five-year limitation period beginning with handover and acceptance of the work, rather than automatically with the building's commissioning. If that starting point is disputed, it is established from the documents and the parties' conduct. This regime is distinct from the minimum warranty periods discussed below.
When does termination require court proceedings?
Court proceedings are required to terminate an agreement that has already transferred, established, recognised or extinguished property rights over immovable property. This is the rule under Article 87(3) ZZD. It does not depend on whether the preliminary agreement scheduled the notarised sale before or after a particular final deadline. What matters is the legal effect of the agreement being terminated.
If the buyer already owns the apartment and has a separate completion contract, ending the construction engagement does not necessarily return the property to the seller. Conversely, if the buyer seeks to terminate the notarised sale itself, it must be established why the unperformed obligation justifies termination of that particular sale. The absence of Act 16 does not automatically produce that result under every contractual arrangement.
What changes when the court opens insolvency proceedings?
Formal insolvency changes not only the financial assessment but also the procedure for protecting your rights. Creditors' claims are established and paid through collective proceedings, rather than each creditor relying solely on an individual case and enforcement. The court decision and entries in the Commercial Register must therefore be checked. Buyers should not wait for the manager to announce that the company has “gone bankrupt”.
The insolvency administrator is appointed by the court and exercises statutory powers to protect and manage assets, examine claims and realise property. The administrator acts within the proceedings, rather than as a particular buyer's personal representative. The property available to satisfy creditors forms the insolvency estate. It may include unsold apartments, rights over land and sums owed to the company. An apartment duly acquired by another person does not become part of that estate merely because it is in the same building.
How should you submit your claim, and what is the deadline?
A buyer seeking repayment, a contractual penalty or damages must submit the claim to the insolvency court. The main deadline is one month from registration of the decision opening the proceedings in the Commercial Register. The application states the claim's basis, amount and any security, supported by the agreement, payment records and other evidence. This is the procedure under Article 685 of the Commerce Act, referred to below as TZ. An informal email to the manager or insolvency administrator does not replace submission of the claim.
The law permits late submission for two months after the main deadline expires. That does not mean the buyer has an equivalent opportunity to wait comfortably for three months. A late creditor bears the additional costs, cannot challenge claims already admitted or distributions already made and, where funds have been distributed, participates in what remains. Claims arising before the proceedings opened cannot be submitted in those proceedings after the additional period expires. Article 688 TZ sets out these consequences.
Filing the application starts the examination of the claim. It does not guarantee admission. The administrator's lists must then be monitored. An objection to an admitted or rejected claim must be filed within seven days of publication of the lists in the Commercial Register under Article 690 TZ. If an objection to rejection is unsuccessful, or the court excludes an admitted claim following another party's objection, a claim seeking a judicial declaration can be brought where the statutory conditions are met. The deadline under Article 694 TZ is 14 days from publication of the order under Article 692(4) TZ. A filing reference for the initial application is therefore not the end of the protective process.
What does it mean if proceedings are opened and immediately stayed?
Sometimes the company lacks assets even to cover the initial costs, and those costs have not been paid in advance. The court then opens the proceedings, declares the debtor insolvent, terminates the business's activity and stays the case under Article 632(1) TZ. The decision does not immediately deregister the company, but leaves a limited period in which to establish whether the proceedings can continue.
The debtor or a creditor can request resumption within one year of registration of the decision by identifying sufficient assets or paying the necessary costs in advance. In this situation, the period for submitting claims begins when the decision to resume proceedings is registered. Without a timely request, the proceedings are terminated and the company is deregistered. This special procedure must not be confused with the ordinary one-month deadline in ongoing proceedings. Nor should it be assumed that every later stay restores deadlines already missed.
Can you still acquire the apartment despite the insolvency?
Insolvency does not automatically exclude a claim to have the preliminary agreement declared final. The reason is that the buyer is exercising a right to obtain a judgment replacing the final transaction, rather than merely seeking payment of money. The Supreme Court of Cassation distinguishes claims seeking this kind of legal change through a judgment from claims for debts submitted in insolvency, including in Decision No. 60126 of 19 July 2022 in Commercial Case No. 480/2020, Second Commercial Division. A successful claim nevertheless still requires an agreement that remains in force, a transfer obligation that has fallen due and the seller's ownership of the promised right.
There is a specific risk here that should not be overlooked. Under Article 644 TZ, the administrator can terminate a contract to which the company is a party and which remains wholly or partly unperformed by giving 15 days' notice. The termination statement must be clear and reach the other party. For a preliminary agreement, this means proper service of the written notice and expiry of the notice period. Once termination takes effect, there is no longer a continuing contractual basis for acquisition under Article 19(3) ZZD.
The buyer may ask the administrator to state whether the agreement will be maintained. Such a request, however, has a consequence quite different from an ordinary enquiry about construction progress. The administrator must respond within 15 days. If there is no response, the agreement is deemed terminated. The request must therefore be assessed against the buyer's aim of acquiring the property. The statutory right to compensation following termination is monetary protection within the insolvency proceedings, rather than an equivalent guarantee that the buyer will receive the home.
Registration of the claim, subsequent transactions and any sale of the property within the proceedings also matter. A new promise signed only by the former manager does not necessarily resolve these issues. The company's representation, the administrator's powers and any necessary court permissions must be established before agreeing to further payments or acquisition.
What happens if you already have a court case or an enforcement agent has started a sale?
In an ordinary claim for repayment of the purchase price, the pending case does not relieve the buyer of submitting the claim in insolvency. Under Article 637 TZ, the monetary proceedings are generally stayed. If the claim is admitted through the prescribed procedure, the stayed case is terminated. If it is not admitted or a statutory challenge arises, the case may continue with the administrator and the relevant parties participating. The two proceedings therefore need to be coordinated.
This does not mean that every form of legal protection against the company must stop. For buyers, the distinction between a monetary claim and protection of ownership of a property wrongly included in the estate is particularly important. The law allows separate protection for a third-party owner. A claim for a final agreement, exercising the acquisition right described above, must also be assessed differently. These rights are not preserved by a simple application to admit a monetary claim.
Individual enforcement against assets in the estate is generally stayed under Article 638 TZ, but a sale already under way needs separate examination. Express exceptions include situations where a successful purchaser has already been declared under GPK. If the balance of the price is not paid within the deadline or the order awarding the property is set aside, enforcement is stayed. The insolvency court may also permit enforcement already commenced against security to continue where a stay would jeopardise the secured creditor's interests. Opening insolvency proceedings is therefore not enough to assume that a sale threatening the apartment has necessarily stopped.
After proceedings open, new individual interim protective measures over assets in the estate cannot be imposed through the ordinary procedure. Earlier attachments cannot be asserted against the insolvency creditors under Article 638(6) TZ. This explains why obtaining interim protection for a monetary claim beforehand does not relieve the buyer of participating in the collective proceedings or give the claim a mortgage creditor's priority.
Does admission of your claim mean that you will get your money back?
Admission establishes the creditor's participation in the proceedings, but payment depends on the available assets and the statutory order of priority. A mortgage creditor has priority over the value of the relevant security. Other statutory categories also rank ahead of ordinary unsecured claims, including the costs of the proceedings and certain public debts. Distribution follows Article 722 TZ. It does not depend on which buyer asked for repayment first or used personal savings to buy a first home.
If insufficient funds remain after the higher-ranking claims have been paid, the buyer may recover only part of the claim. There may be nothing left for them at all. In other words, a successful court case and admission of a claim establish whether a debt is owed and how much, but do not create missing assets. This is why the possibility of lawfully organising completion deserves consideration alongside claims against the original debtor.
Can the owners complete the building with a different contractor?
The original contractor has no exclusive right to finish the building. Another company can be appointed, but the first step is to establish who is legally entitled to commission the work. This is the first practical question because collecting money does not, by itself, give anyone the right to build on someone else's property.
If the buyers already own their apartments or the corresponding rights to build, those property rights provide the starting point for arranging completion. Where they have only preliminary agreements, someone else still owns the property. Their involvement must then be organised by acquiring the promised rights or through an agreement and representation that allow the work to be commissioned on behalf of the proper construction client. In other words, a person can fund construction without being the owner, but payment alone does not entitle that person to exercise someone else's rights.
This distinction becomes particularly important in insolvency. If the company still owns unsold units, rights over the land or facilities serving the building, the powers of the insolvency administrator and the court must be respected. An agreement with the manager alone cannot resolve a matter over which the manager no longer has independent authority. Ownership and representation must therefore be checked before the new contractor is appointed.
Once rough construction has been reached and separate units belong to different people, condominium ownership relationships arise. This is a system for managing common property, rather than automatic succession to the developer's rights and obligations. The developer's unsold units do not become condominium property. The owners need a collective decision on what will be done to the common areas, who will commission the work and how funds will be collected and accounted for. This does not mean that every matter can be settled by a single collective vote. Completing the façade, furnishing an individual apartment and acquiring someone else's land involve different assets and different legal grounds.
What happens if an owner disagrees or refuses to pay?
To establish whether a dissenting owner must contribute, the source of that obligation must first be identified. A lawful resolution of the general meeting on a matter within its powers also binds owners who voted against it or did not attend. A private agreement between several buyers, however, binds its parties. It does not make the remaining owners liable for contributions under the agreed budget.
Both the nature of the work and the required majority are essential. The Condominium Ownership Management Act (ZUES) requires at least 51 per cent of all ownership shares for major repairs and major renovation, and at least 75 per cent for expenditure on improvements and taking out a loan. These thresholds cannot simply be applied to every instance of initial completion. Necessary work on common property must be distinguished from improvements and work affecting individual property rights or rights belonging to third parties. That distinction determines the general meeting's powers, the majority required and how the cost is allocated.
For example, a resolution to raise funds for the communal electrical installation does not transfer ownership of someone else's transformer station to the apartment owners. If that facility needs to be acquired or a right established over another person's land, the relevant transaction must be concluded with the participation of the people entitled to dispose of those rights. The general meeting's minutes may authorise negotiations, but they do not replace a notarial deed where the law requires one.
If a contribution imposed by a general meeting resolution remains unpaid, the condominium manager may apply for an order for payment after the specified deadline expires. Where no deadline is stated, Article 38 ZUES provides for 14 days from communication under Article 16(7). An owner may, in turn, ask the district court where the building is located to set aside an unlawful resolution within 30 days of receiving it through the same procedure. A challenge does not suspend implementation unless the court orders otherwise. Properly convening the meeting, recording its decisions and communicating them are therefore part of securing the completion funding, rather than formalities that can be left until later.
How should a change of contractor be arranged?
The new contract should clearly distinguish work already completed, work requiring correction and work that remains to be done. Before the site is handed over, the relationship with the original contractor must be terminated or amended as appropriate, and a detailed inventory prepared of the condition, defects, available materials and construction records. This preserves evidence of the earlier non-performance and defines precisely what the new company is undertaking.
Materials left on the site cannot be treated as belonging to no one. They may belong to a supplier who retained ownership until payment, or to the insolvent company. Before they are used, it must be clear who has authority to make them available. The same applies to equipment, machinery and facilities physically present in the building but not acquired by its owners.
The remaining work should be agreed in specific quantities, with a price, applicable tax, deadlines and an acceptance procedure. It is sensible to link payments to measured and accepted work, while providing a process for approving additional work and securing the correction of defects. Otherwise, the initial contract price may prove to be only the beginning of repeated demands for further payment with no clearly defined result.
Changing contractor does not mean that the new company assumes liability for earlier advances, contractual penalties or damages. A separate legal basis is needed for such an assumption. Care is also required to ensure that the agreement to resume work does not contain a waiver of existing claims against the original debtor. Buyers need to know whether they are paying for additional work, settling a dispute or giving up a claim, because the consequences differ.
Alongside the contractor, the designers and any required construction supervisor must be engaged. The supervisor oversees lawful execution and the recording of the work so that a properly supported assessment of the building's fitness can ultimately be made. For an ordinary apartment building, supervision remains necessary even where the owners arrange completion themselves. The rule in Article 168(2) ZUT covers categories I to V. The exception for small low-rise residential and holiday houses is tied to a gross floor area of up to 100 square metres for the whole building under Article 14(2) of the Chamber of Builders Act. It does not concern an apartment of up to 100 square metres within a larger block.
For category V construction completed under a permit issued before 30 March 2019, transitional section 48 preserves the earlier regime involving technical management for both completion and commissioning. The category, floor area and permit date must therefore be checked together. Merely describing the building as category V is not enough to dispense with construction supervision and the supervisor's final report.
What should you do if construction stopped before Act 14?
Where the structure is not yet complete, the first task is to establish whether it can lawfully and safely be finished. Payments already made and the presence of a permit in the file are not enough. The permit's validity, the right to build on the land and the condition of the existing work must all be checked. Each of these issues can independently prevent work from resuming.
For an ordinary residential building, the building permit ceases to have effect if construction does not begin within three years after it becomes effective, or if rough construction, including the roof, is not completed within five years after commencement. The statutory records must be checked to establish when construction began, rather than simply relying on the day machinery arrived on the site. This matters because the legally ascertainable dates determine whether the deadlines have been met.
The construction client may seek revalidation within three months after the relevant period expires. The authority decides within 14 days, and revalidation is available once under Article 153 ZUT. This is not an unrestricted opportunity to renew an old permit whenever the project is delayed. If the permit has ceased to have effect and can no longer be revalidated, work cannot continue under it. The conditions for obtaining fresh authorisation must then be established before the remaining construction work is contracted.
The right to build granted over someone else's land is a separate issue. Article 67 of the Property Act provides a five-year limitation period for exercising it. As a rule, the period begins when the grant takes legal effect and does not restart with each resale. Exercise of the right depends on reaching rough construction for the building or a duly authorised independent phase, as explained above.
In other words, a valid or revalidated building permit does not restore an extinguished right to build over another person's property. Conversely, holding that property right does not allow work under a permit that has ceased to have effect. The right to build is not automatically removed from the register at the end of the fifth year, but failure to exercise it creates a risk that the landowner will invoke its extinguishment. Grounds for suspending or interrupting the limitation period also matter in that assessment.
Once the rights have been clarified, the structural engineer and construction supervisor assess what has been built and whether the period of inactivity has caused damage. Surveys, testing and strengthening are commissioned where necessary. On that basis, the new contractor completes the structure in accordance with the approved design, while the inspections and work are recorded. This leads to acceptance of the structure and certification of the rough construction stage actually achieved.
If construction has been halted by an administrative order, changing the company does not lift the prohibition. The stated grounds must be remedied and continuation authorised by the authority that issued the order. For categories I to III, this is the competent DNSK authority, while for categories IV to VI it is the mayor or an authorised official. The new construction contract should reflect that sequence rather than promise an immediate start while a prohibition remains in force.
How do you complete a building from Act 14 to Act 16?
Where a building is described as having reached Act 14, the first check is whether rough construction has actually been achieved and duly certified. Engineers then compare the existing work with the approved design and identify what remains. If the building has stood unprotected for years, the earlier structural acceptance record does not remove the need to assess its present condition. It establishes acceptance at a particular time, but does not prove that no damage occurred afterwards.
The findings should be converted into a priced bill of quantities. This is a schedule of the specific types and quantities of work and their prices, providing a basis for the budget, competing quotations and the contract. A general promise to “finish everything up to Act 16” does not reveal whether the price includes strengthening, a lift, a transformer station or reconstruction of missing records. Defining the scope enables owners to compare offers and assess whether the funds collected can secure lawful use.
If the new contractor proposes changes that substantially depart from the design, the first question is whether the law permits that particular alteration. Permissible substantial changes must be approved and reflected in the construction documents before execution under Article 154 ZUT. As-built documentation serves a different purpose. It records what has actually been constructed within the limits permitted by law and cannot retrospectively legalise a substantial unlawful departure.
Completion itself covers the specified façades, windows and doors, insulation, installations, common areas, lifts and external works. Records must be prepared as the work progresses. For example, an installation that will be covered by screed or cladding is inspected and accepted before it is concealed. If that step is missed, final acceptance may require additional testing or opening up sections already finished. An apparent saving on paperwork then becomes an actual cost.
Utility connections, the necessary access and the site works required by the design must be completed alongside the building. Once it is fit for acceptance, the participants draw up Act 15, the recorded outstanding items are addressed and the commissioning file is assembled. Only then does the construction client apply for the final document under the procedure applicable to the building's category. The route from Act 14 to Act 16 therefore involves actual construction, its proper acceptance and administrative review, rather than simply preparing two more documents.
If rough construction was lawfully achieved within the permit's deadline, a further period of several years without Act 16 does not, by itself, mean that the permit has ceased to have effect because the structure was not completed. Efforts should then focus on the specific outstanding works and obstacles, rather than assuming that the entire authorisation procedure must start again.
What remains to be done if the building already has Act 15?
After Act 15, the question changes. A record already confirms the building's fitness for acceptance, but it must be established why lawful use has not followed. The act and its attachments are examined, outstanding items are checked and its precise coverage is established for the building or phase to be commissioned. An inspection of the present condition follows. Acceptance years earlier does not rule out subsequent leaks, damage or unauthorised alterations.
Consider a building with completed apartments and common areas but no finished transformer station. Further internal refurbishment will not remove the obstacle to Act 16. The rights over the facility and its land, the construction documents, the arrangements with the utility operator and the cost of construction and connection need to be clarified. In another building, the work may already be complete, but the original contractor may not have handed over the file. The main task is then to collect and check the documentation, rather than commission the whole building again.
Once the particular cause has been identified, the necessary repairs, connections and documents can be arranged. Earlier records that were properly prepared retain their significance. A change of contractor does not automatically require a new Act 14 or repetition of the entire construction process. New work and changes must nevertheless be recorded so that the final assessment concerns the building as it actually stands.
For that reason, the statement “only Act 16 remains” should always be checked against the documents and a site inspection. It may mean that a complete file is ready to be submitted. It may instead conceal missing infrastructure, a substantial defect or a dispute over rights. The difference determines the action required, the funding and the realistic completion timetable.
BSLC · Legal analysis · Bulgaria
What happens next if the building has Act 14 or Act 15?
The starting point is to identify what is actually preventing completion.
How does completion proceed after Act 14?
- The lawyer establishes title and encumbrances while engineers assess the structure.
- The construction clients arrange a shared budget, representation and the necessary contracts.
- The new contractor completes the building and infrastructure in accordance with the approved design.
- After acceptance under Act 15 and rectification of defects, the final application is prepared.
What remains after Act 15?
- The construction supervisor examines the act, its reservations and the building’s present condition.
- The review identifies whether a defect, missing document or unfinished utility connection is blocking progress.
- The construction client arranges the necessary works and completes the records.
- The application follows once the obstacles are removed, without automatically repeating every earlier act.
For categories one to three, DNSK issues a use permit following a State Acceptance Commission and Protocol 16. For categories four and five, the authority that issued the building permit issues the commissioning certificate.
A finished apartment is insufficient if the common areas, access and building services do not allow safe use.
What if construction records are missing or the contractor refuses to sign?
A missing document can mean two different things. In the first situation, the act was prepared but a copy was never handed over or has been lost. Existing copies should then be sought from the municipality, construction supervisor, designers, contractor and other participants. In the second situation, the necessary inspection or its recording never took place. It is not enough for someone to prepare a new sheet bearing an earlier date. What was actually built, and whether it complies with the design and safety requirements, must be established.
This may require a geodetic survey, designers' opinions, a structural survey, testing or opening up concealed work. Assessment based on available records and additional technical evidence is addressed in the DNSK and MRRB guidance and opinions on missing construction records. This is not general permission to replace any missing act with an expert report of one's choosing. The evidence must allow a reliable assessment of the particular work. If it reveals unlawful construction, recording that construction does not make it lawful.
When construction is interrupted, Form 10 records the condition at suspension, while Form 11 concerns continuation after the causes have been removed. For categories IV and V, these forms are not included in the general list of mandatory records, but may be prepared when needed at a participant's request. Regardless of that distinction, an inventory when the contractor changes is essential. Without it, proving which defects already existed and what the new contractor is responsible for becomes more difficult.
Where the problem is a participant's failure to attend, the law provides a procedure to prevent the records from being blocked indefinitely. The contractor or another interested participant sends a written invitation, while the construction supervisor also has an independent duty to request preparation of the necessary act. If the invited representative does not attend within 24 hours after the time stated in the invitation, those present sign the act and record the invitation's number and date. The absent party is replaced by the authority that issued the building permit or an official authorised by it, in accordance with Article 5 of Ordinance No. 3.
In other words, the original contractor's absence is not dealt with by deleting the space for its signature. It is addressed through a provable invitation and lawful substitution. The absence of the signature of a duly invited party that fails to attend does not, by itself, invalidate the act. In insolvency, invitations must take account of the company's current representation, including the insolvency administrator's powers.
A different situation arises where a participant attends and disputes the technical findings. For disagreements concerning construction rules and execution requirements, Article 5(8) of Ordinance No. 3 provides for a determination by the construction supervisor and the person exercising technical control over the structural design. An interested party may ask the regional construction control directorate, RDNSK, to revoke the supervisor's relevant decision, instruction or order within seven days of signing a record of disagreement. For category V construction where supervision is not required, RDNSK resolves these disputes. The ordinance gives the head of RDNSK seven days to decide in both situations. This procedure for technical disagreements does not resolve a separate civil dispute about payment and does not permit unsafe work to be accepted merely to complete the paperwork.
Can a finished apartment be left without Act 16 because of common areas or infrastructure?
Yes, because living in the apartment depends on more than its interior finish. It must be accessible through safe common areas, installations must operate as designed and the building must be connected to the necessary utility networks. Flooring, painted walls and furniture therefore cannot compensate for a missing power supply, an unsafe staircase or unimplemented fire safety measures.
A temporary construction electricity supply serves the building works and does not replace a permanent connection for the completed building. Paying the operator's connection fee does not prove that the facility has been built and accepted either. The whole sequence must be traced from the agreed connection to the facilities actually constructed and their documentation. Otherwise, a buyer may see a working socket in the apartment even though the building has no lawfully established supply for its intended use.
If a cable or water main crosses someone else's property, the right to use that route must be secured. Where a transformer station, water main or another facility constitutes a separate construction project, it has its own construction documents and procedure. The problem cannot therefore always be resolved by instructing the company finishing the façade. A separate design, permit, agreement with the operator and participation by another landowner may be needed.
Street access also needs to be considered in light of Constitutional Court Decision No. 17/2021. It removed part of the former general prohibition on commissioning buildings in areas with medium-rise and high-rise development before the streets were built. An unfinished municipal street cannot therefore automatically justify refusal in every case. Specific requirements for safe and lawful access remain, however. The law also retains a special requirement for normal access through connecting streets, roads or paths in resorts, holiday and golf developments, water parks and other recreational areas. In a dispute, the precise unmet requirement and its application to the particular building must be established.
Can you obtain a separate Act 16 for your apartment alone?
A separate unit of ownership is not necessarily an independent phase for commissioning purposes. An apartment may have its own cadastral identifier and title deed while relying on communal stairs, installations and facilities that are not yet fit for use. Its identification as a separate property for sale does not detach it from the technical requirements for safe occupation of the building.
Separate commissioning is possible for a duly authorised phase or part that can be built and used independently under Article 152(2) ZUT. This requires a suitable design, the necessary common areas, installations and access, and completion of the relevant phase. If the original documents do not provide for such a phase, the possibility of a lawful amendment must be examined. In other words, independence here is both legal and technical. It does not arise merely because one owner has finished the interior of an apartment.
Who applies for Act 16, and how long does the procedure take?
The construction client or a person authorised to act on its behalf submits the application. Where completion is organised collectively, it must be clear which owners are acting as construction clients and on what basis the chosen representative submits the documents. Payment under a preliminary agreement does not automatically confer that status. Authorisation, in turn, permits representation without transferring ownership of the building.
The documents must establish more than the building's existence. They must show that it was authorised, constructed and prepared for lawful use. The title document or grant of the right to build establishes the construction client's legal basis. The permit and approved design show what was authorised to be built. The acts, records and permissible as-built documentation connect that authorisation to the work actually performed. The cadastral information identifies the property for which commissioning is sought.
The remainder of the file demonstrates technical readiness. An ordinary new residential building requires a technical passport and an energy performance certificate. Connection documents and the necessary installation tests are provided. The specified fire safety measures must have been implemented and escape routes must be fit for use. A lift also requires a favourable opinion from the authority responsible for its technical supervision. This is a specialised safety assessment, distinct from construction supervision of the building as a whole.
The construction supervisor's final report brings together the review of the construction documents, the acts prepared, compliance with the design, utility connections and fitness for commissioning. It cannot properly be reduced to a signature on a standard form where evidence of substantial work is missing. The statutory and transitional exceptions explained above determine when that report is not required. For other ordinary residential buildings, it provides the essential link between completion of the work and the final administrative decision.
How does the procedure work for category IV and V buildings?
For categories IV and V, the application goes to the authority that issued the building permit. It checks the completeness of the documents, may inspect the site and issues a commissioning certificate. This procedure does not involve the State Acceptance Commission used for categories I to III, and no separate Form 16 record from such a commission is awaited.
Where the file is in order, Article 177(3) ZUT provides seven days from receipt of the application. That period covers administrative review and the decision. It does not include the months that may be needed to build a transformer station, correct defects or assemble missing construction records. Deficiencies in the documents must be remedied, while a building that does not meet the requirements does not become entitled to a certificate merely because a complete set of documents has been submitted.
How does the procedure work for category I to III buildings?
For categories I to III, the construction client asks DNSK to appoint a State Acceptance Commission. The commission examines the building and documentation and prepares a Form 16 record recommending that permission be granted or refused. The competent authority issues the use permit on the basis of that record and the other required documents. The record and permit are successive but distinct documents. A favourable recommendation from the commission should not be confused with the permit itself.
The commission is appointed, or its appointment refused, within 14 working days of receipt of the request. It has up to 10 working days to carry out its work, with a possible reasoned extension of up to a further 10 calendar days. The chair submits the record within five working days after the final meeting, and the authority decides within five working days of its submission. These periods are laid down in Ordinance No. 2 on commissioning. They are not a promise that every building will be commissioned within their combined total. Refusal, deficiencies or the need for further work will change the actual course of the procedure.
A practical timetable must start with the most significant unmet requirement. Where the only missing items are documents already prepared but not handed over, the task is one thing. Where construction on someone else's land or correction of a structural problem remains necessary, it is quite another. Only after that assessment can a realistic sequence be established for execution, acceptance, application and decision.
What can you do if the application is refused?
The first distinction is between a justified refusal because a requirement remains unmet and an incorrect application of the law. If the building has an unsafe installation or the façade required by the design is unfinished, the necessary work must be carried out. A court challenge does not replace completion. If, however, the authority demands an inapplicable document, disregards evidence submitted or incorrectly identifies a legal obstacle, the refusal may be appealed.
An ordinary express refusal by the municipal authority or DNSK is challenged through that authority before the administrative court where the property is located, within 14 days of notification under Article 215 ZUT. Where the authority fails to decide within the required period and a deemed refusal arises, the general time limit under Article 149(2) of the Administrative Procedure Code is two months after the decision deadline expires. Evidence of submission and any notices received should therefore be retained. The latest conversation with an official does not start a new appeal period.
How much will completion cost from Act 14 or Act 15?
There is no universal price for “obtaining Act 16” because the main expense is not the document itself. The cost concerns everything without which the building cannot be accepted and used. At Act 14, a substantial amount of construction usually remains. At Act 15, there is often less work outstanding, but an unfinished transformer station, a serious defect or an unresolved route for a utility connection can account for a large share of the required budget.
The actual estimate is prepared for the whole building or a permissible independent phase after a technical assessment. It includes the remaining construction work, correction of existing defects, external infrastructure, design and supervision services, testing, documents, fees and the necessary legal work. A justified contingency is provided separately for risks that cannot be fully quantified at the outset. That contingency does not relieve the contractor of the obligation to justify each additional item of work.
Quotations must cover the same scope and clearly state whether VAT is included. A lower offer may simply exclude utility connections, testing or part of the communal work. Comparison also requires clarity about the area used to calculate a price per square metre. A building's gross floor area is not the sum of the apartments' net internal areas because it also includes areas outside the individual homes.
The following calculations are entirely hypothetical examples of the method, rather than market valuations or BSLC quotations. They assume a building with a gross floor area of 2,000 square metres. The comparison shows how construction work, infrastructure, services and a contingency combine to form an overall budget in two different starting situations.
BSLC · Legal analysis · Bulgaria
How is the completion budget calculated?
These are hypothetical examples for a building with 2,000 square metres of gross floor area. They illustrate the calculation method, not market prices or quotations.
What makes up the budget after Act 14?
The total hypothetical budget is 805 000 EUR.
This equals EUR 402.50 per square metre of gross floor area.
- The allowance for building works is
- 560 000 EUR.
- The allowance for infrastructure is
- 90 000 EUR.
- The allowance for services and documents is
- 50 000 EUR.
- The base budget is
- 700 000 EUR.
- The hypothetical reserve of 15 per cent is
- 105 000 EUR.
What makes up the budget after Act 15?
The total hypothetical budget is 172 500 EUR.
This equals EUR 86.25 per square metre of gross floor area.
- The allowance for building works is
- 80 000 EUR.
- The allowance for infrastructure is
- 50 000 EUR.
- The allowance for services and documents is
- 20 000 EUR.
- The base budget is
- 150 000 EUR.
- The hypothetical reserve of 15 per cent is
- 22 500 EUR.
The figures include applicable VAT. Property purchases, mortgage debt and separate disputes are excluded. A real budget requires a technical survey and an itemised estimate. The 15 per cent reserve is an assumption for this example only.
The resulting price per square metre helps compare the overall cost. It does not automatically determine an individual owner's contribution by multiplication against the apartment's net internal area. Allocation must follow the legal basis for the expenditure, ownership shares, valid resolutions and agreements, and any individual work. If acquiring someone else's land, settling mortgage debt or furnishing an apartment is also necessary, those costs must be identified separately so that they do not fall outside an otherwise apparently adequate budget.
If you financed the purchase with your own bank loan, a halt in construction does not automatically suspend your repayments. The loan agreement is a separate legal relationship, and the developer's promise does not change its terms. Any deferral, restructuring or further financing must be agreed with the bank. This forms part of assessing whether completion is financially achievable for the individual buyer, even where a technical solution exists for the project as a whole.
Who will be responsible for defects after completion?
The new contractor is responsible for the work it undertakes and performs. Earlier breaches do not disappear when it arrives, but neither do they automatically become its responsibility. If, for example, it repairs existing waterproofing and installs a new system, the contract and acceptance records must distinguish the two types of work. This makes it possible to establish what it agreed to repair, what it built itself and against whom a particular claim should be brought.
Guarantee periods depend on the type of work. Under the current minimum periods in Ordinance No. 2, the guarantee for a newly constructed structure is 10 years, while major repair and reconstruction of an existing structure carry eight years. Insulation work in a non-aggressive environment and new internal installations carry seven years. Insulation in an aggressive environment, major repair and reconstruction of internal installations, and other ordinary construction and finishing work carry five years. It is therefore incorrect to apply a single period to a varied package of work without checking the relevant category for each item.
The contract may provide longer periods, but not periods shorter than the applicable statutory minima. They begin when the construction project is commissioned. Older contracts require consideration of the transitional rule under which the 2019 amendments apply to contracts entered into after those amendments came into force on 12 November 2019. Where a building is completed after a lengthy interruption, the original contract, the newly commissioned work and the regime applicable to each obligation must therefore be examined together.
A right under a guarantee does not mean that an insolvent contractor will be able to pay for repairs. The responsible party, the basis of the claim and a realistic means of recovery must be established. Mandatory professional insurance under Article 171 ZUT is likewise not a guarantee of completion funding if the company becomes insolvent. It covers liability for harm caused by unlawful professional acts or omissions within the relevant policy coverage. A claim against the insurer requires identifiable harm and a basis for the insured participant's liability, rather than merely insufficient funds to finish the building.
Where should you begin, and how can BSLC help?
The starting point is a review of what you already have. The agreement and amendments show what was promised and when it should have been performed. Payment records establish the sums paid. A notarial deed, if one exists, records the subject matter and legal basis of the acquisition, while construction documents and correspondence help identify where the process stopped. You do not need to locate the entire file yourself before seeking assistance. Part of the legal work is to establish what is missing, who holds it and how it can be obtained.
At BSLC, we consider these documents together because the best course of action is not determined solely by the latest signed construction act. A buyer may wish to acquire the property, seek repayment, protect ownership already obtained or participate in collective completion. Choosing the right route requires the contractual rights, ownership and encumbrances, the debtor's position and the technical prospects of completing the building to be assessed together.
Where the objective is Act 16, legal assistance includes arranging the authority to commission the work and representation, dealing with the original and replacement contractors, securing the necessary owners' resolutions and protecting the client's position before the administration. These steps are coordinated with the engineers' assessment and a realistic budget. The lawyer does not replace the structural engineer or construction supervisor, but must establish the legal basis on which their work can lead to a usable building.
The first question is therefore not the price of signing one more document. It is what rights you have and what specifically must be done to secure the promised home or protect the money invested. To discuss your circumstances, you can contact BSLC's construction law team.
Which legislation and official sources support this article?
The relevant legal provisions and court decisions are identified alongside the questions they address. The following links lead to the official Bulgarian texts of the main legislation.

.webp)






