A BSLC client contacted us after buying an apartment in a resort area. The transaction had been completed before a notary and the price paid. Shortly afterwards, however, it emerged that the seller had deliberately concealed a serious ownership dispute and pending court proceedings. The buyer was already registered as the owner but faced a real risk of losing the property. The inevitable question was whether this amounted to fraud in a property transaction and how it could be proved.
Fraud in the transfer of real estate is one of the most complex defects of consent. It requires more than an unfavourable bargain. There must be deliberate deception. An incorrect legal classification or weak evidence often leads to a claim being dismissed even where the property sale was in fact fraudulent.
Early advice from a property lawyer is decisive for several reasons.
- The time available to bring an action to set the transaction aside is limited.
- Evidence must be collected from the outset.
- Several claims often need to be combined, including claims concerning invalidity, ownership and damages.
BSLC assists with situations such as these.
- Suspected fraud in a property transaction 🏠
- Disputes over a notarised transaction and concealed circumstances
- Protecting a property buyer against a seller acting in bad faith
- Property fraud litigation and claims for damages
- Protecting ownership in a real estate dispute
What constitutes property fraud under Bulgarian law?
Fraud is governed by the Bulgarian Obligations and Contracts Act, commonly abbreviated as ZZD. The closest comparable concepts in common law are fraud and misrepresentation. Under Article 27 ZZD, contracts concluded as a result of fraud are voidable rather than void.
Article 29 ZZD defines the substance of fraud as deliberate deception that induces the other party to enter into the transaction. Legal scholarship and case law treat this as a defect of consent. The declared intention does not correspond to the person's true intention because it was formed under the influence of fraudulent conduct.
Several essential elements must be established.
- Intentional conduct involving positive acts or the deliberate concealment of material facts
- Deception that creates a false understanding on the buyer's part
- A causal link, meaning that the transaction would not have been concluded without the fraud
- Materiality of the mistaken belief, meaning that the fact must have been decisive
In real estate transactions, this most often involves the following conduct.
- Concealing encumbrances, including attachments, mortgages and litigation
- Presenting false ownership documents
- Concealing existing third-party rights
- Using sham transactions or front persons
Not every disadvantageous term or inaccurate statement amounts to fraud. The law requires intentional conduct, rather than mere negligence.
How is fraud in a property sale proved?
Proof is the most difficult part of any real estate dispute based on fraud. The burden rests on the party alleging fraud, usually the buyer.
The court does not accept assumptions. Specific facts and the connections between them must be established.
The main categories of evidence are the following.
- Written evidence
- Preliminary contracts
- Correspondence, including emails and messages
- Declarations made by the seller
- Ownership documents
- Notarial documents
- The notarial deed
- Documents attached to the transaction
- Certificates of encumbrances
- Witness testimony
- People present during negotiations
- Intermediaries and estate agents
- Expert evidence
- Handwriting examinations where forgery is suspected
- Technical assessments of the property's condition
Proving the intentional nature of the conduct is crucial. For example, evidence that the seller knew about pending litigation and failed to disclose it strongly supports an allegation of fraud. If the information was publicly available and the buyer could have checked it, proving fraud becomes considerably more difficult.
A practical point is that fraud can also consist of silence where a party had a duty to disclose information. This frequently arises in property transactions.
A common mistake is to rely solely on the claim that the deal was unfavourable. That is not enough. A deliberate fraudulent scheme must be demonstrated.
In such cases, professional legal advice on property fraud is essential to building an effective evidential strategy.
What are the legal consequences and how can the buyer obtain protection?
Where fraud is proved, the law provides several remedies that are often used together.
1. An action to set the transaction aside
The principal claim is an action under Articles 27 and 29 ZZD to set the contract aside. Its legal effects are removed retroactively, or ex tunc, as though the transaction had never existed.
In practical terms, this means returning the property to the seller and returning the purchase price to the buyer.
This action is subject to a time limit, usually three years from discovery of the fraud.
2. A claim for financial loss
Regardless of the setting aside of the contract, the injured party is entitled to compensation. This includes the price paid, transaction expenses and lost profits.
The legal basis lies in the general rules on tort and contractual liability.
3. Claims concerning ownership
Depending on the circumstances, it may be necessary to bring a declaratory ownership claim, an action for recovery of possession based on ownership if the property has been taken away, or to register the statement of claim so that it can be relied upon against third parties.
4. A claim that the transaction is void in particular cases
Although fraud generally makes a contract voidable, in practice it often occurs alongside other grounds under Article 26 ZZD. Examples include a sham transaction, lack of consent or a transaction contrary to the law.
In these circumstances, an action seeking a declaration of nullity may also be brought.
5. Procedural measures
In a real estate dispute, it is important to register the statement of claim promptly, seek interim protection such as an attachment over the property, and collect evidence even before proceedings are started.
Clients often underestimate the situation and seek a lawyer's help too late. Proving the case then becomes considerably harder.
If you face a similar situation, an early consultation with a property lawyer may be decisive both for the outcome of the case and for limiting financial losses.

.webp)






