Clients often come to BSLC convinced that they have suffered loss, for example following a road accident, poor repair work or unlawful conduct by a business partner. They have expense records, medical expert opinions or even witnesses. Yet the court dismisses their claim. The reason is almost always the same. The causal link between the conduct and the loss has not been established.
This is one of the most critical elements of any damages claim. Even where there is loss and unlawful conduct, liability does not arise without a clear connection between them. Many cases are lost at this point because the claimant has not proved that the loss was a direct consequence of the particular conduct.
We can assist in situations such as the following.
- Compensation refused because no causal link has been established
- A dispute with an insurer over the cause of damage
- A claim for financial loss arising from a breach of contract
- A tort claim involving a road accident, medical error or construction work
- The need for a strategy to prove loss in court ⚖️
What does causation mean under Bulgarian law?
Bulgarian law treats causation as an essential element of liability for damage. This follows from the general rules on tort liability in the Bulgarian Obligations and Contracts Act, known as ZZD. A close continental-law equivalent is French tort liability under the Code civil, which also requires a direct causal connection between faute and dommage, or fault and damage.
Article 45(1) ZZD requires every person to make good the damage they have culpably caused to another. Although the provision does not expressly define causation, the requirement is logically contained in the reference to causing damage.
Legal theory and case law recognise several conditions that must all be satisfied before liability arises.
- Conduct consisting of an act or omission
- Damage
- Unlawfulness
- Fault, which is presumed under Article 45(2) ZZD
- A causal link
Causation means that the loss is a direct and immediate consequence of the particular conduct. This excludes coincidences, indirect or remote consequences and damage caused by independent factors.
The distinction between factual and legal causation is especially important. Not every factual connection has legal significance. The court must determine whether the particular conduct constitutes the legally relevant cause of the damage.
For example, where someone suffers a health impairment after an accident but also has pre-existing illnesses, the court examines whether the accident was the principal cause of the harm or merely coincided with other factors.
Insurance law expressly emphasises this requirement. Compensation is payable only where there is a direct and immediate causal connection between the insured event and the loss.
Who bears the burden of proof and what evidence establishes causation?
Proof is one of the most frequently underestimated aspects of these cases. Civil proceedings follow the principle that each party must establish the facts on which its claims are based.
For a damages claim, this means that the claimant must prove both the loss and the causal link. Fault is presumed under Article 45(2) ZZD, but the other elements are not.
The supporting materials likewise emphasise that the injured party bears the burden of proving the relevant elements.
In practice, causation is established through a combination of evidence.
- Documents such as contracts, reports and medical records
- Witness testimony
- Expert opinions, which are central in most cases
- Technical or medical analyses
A court-appointed expert opinion is usually the strongest form of evidence. Examples include automotive technical expertise in a road accident case, forensic medical expertise in a medical case and technical expertise for construction defects.
The court is not automatically bound by an expert opinion, but in practice it is often decisive in establishing causation.
It is important to understand that the requirement is not absolute certainty but a sufficient degree of probability to convince the court. Nevertheless, any remaining doubt operates against the party bearing the burden of proof.
Practical mistakes that often lead to dismissal include proving only the loss without explaining its cause, failing to obtain expert evidence, presenting contradictory evidence and failing to establish the timing of the damage.
In such cases, even genuine loss may remain uncompensated.
How does the court decide whether the connection is direct and immediate?
This is the central practical question. The court carries out a comprehensive assessment of all the facts.
A key criterion is whether the damage is a normal and typical consequence of the conduct. Causation may be rejected where the result is unusual, arises from exceptional circumstances or the causal sequence is interrupted by another event.
Law also addresses this through the concept of a break in the chain of causation. Such a break may occur where a third party independently causes the loss, the injured person's own conduct creates a new cause or an event of force majeure intervenes.
The court also analyses the sequence of events. It is important to identify the initial act, how the causal process developed and whether other factors intervened.
In some cases there may be contributory causation. Liability then remains but is reduced.
The standard for contractual liability is similar, with the additional requirement that the damage be foreseeable. This follows from Article 82 ZZD, which limits compensation to damage that is a direct and immediate consequence of non-performance.
In practice, not all loss is recoverable. Only damage that has the required causal connection and is legally relevant qualifies.
When preparing a damages case, it is therefore essential to construct a clear chain of causation demonstrating the following sequence.
- The specific conduct
- The events that followed it
- The final harmful result
Without this logical and evidential sequence, the claim remains vulnerable.
If you need to prove loss or have already been refused compensation, the most sensible approach is to develop an evidence strategy from the outset. Further information about our work is available in the civil law section. For an assessment of a particular case, you can request a consultation.

.webp)






