A client contacts BSLC with a concern. They transferred an apartment to a relative as a formality to avoid creditors. The transaction was documented as a sale, but no money was actually paid. Years later, their relationship deteriorates and the apparent buyer refuses to return the apartment. This is the classic problem of a sham property transaction, where the documented agreement conceals another transaction or is not intended to produce legal effects at all.
Such situations are not uncommon. A sham or simulated transaction carries serious risks, including loss of ownership, tax consequences and disputes with third parties. Bulgarian law allows these transactions to be challenged, but a sound strategy and proper evidence are essential.
BSLC assists in cases involving apparent sales concealing gifts or the reverse, concealed property sales intended to avoid taxes, transfers through nominees, ownership disputes following sham transactions and claims for nullity.
What is a sham transaction, and when can it be challenged?
Bulgarian law regulates simulated transactions through the Obligations and Contracts Act, which reflects general continental obligations law principles within the EU. The principal provisions are Article 26(2) and Article 17.
The rule is clear. Apparent agreements are void and do not produce legal effects from the outset.
Two main forms must be distinguished.
- Absolute simulation exists where the parties intend no legal consequences, such as an apparent sale without any intended transfer.
- Relative simulation conceals a different genuine transaction, such as a sale disguising a gift.
For relative simulation, Article 17(1) provides that the concealed transaction applies if it meets the statutory requirements.
This distinction has major practical consequences. A sale concealing a gift is governed by the rules on gifts. If the concealed agreement is itself invalid, no legal consequences arise.
A challenge is possible where there is no genuine intention to conclude the declared transaction, the parties agreed to create an appearance or a different agreement is concealed.
Common property examples include sham sales between relatives, deeds recording an understated price and transfers through nominees.
How is a sham or concealed property sale proved?
Proof is the most difficult part of litigation over this type of transaction. Different forms of evidence are available, but statutory restrictions apply.
The strongest evidence is a counter-letter, a document disclosing the parties’ actual intentions. It may acknowledge that the transaction is apparent, describe the true agreement or provide for return of the property. Where such a document exists, the court regards simulation as established.
Other evidence can include preliminary contracts, receipts, bank transfers, indirect indicators such as non-payment and the parties’ conduct, and witness testimony subject to restrictions.
Article 164 of the Bulgarian Code of Civil Procedure restricts testimony contradicting a written document unless the parties agree or an exception applies.
Key indicators include no real payment for a sale, the apparent seller continuing to possess the property, tax motives such as a minimal recorded price and close relationships between the parties.
Simulation must be established as a shared intention. Both parties must have agreed that the transaction was merely apparent. Without that agreement, a sham cannot be established.
Which claims can be brought, and how do proceedings work?
The main procedural remedy is a declaratory claim for nullity or disclosure of simulation.
The legal basis commonly includes Article 26(2) of the Obligations and Contracts Act for nullity, Article 17 for the concealed agreement’s effects, and Article 124(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure for a declaratory claim.
Under Article 109 of the Code, the competent court is the court where the property is located.
The proceedings may seek a declaration that the apparent transaction is void, recognition of the true transaction or a determination of ownership.
Claims are often combined. Nullity may be joined with a vindicatory claim recovering the property. In an inheritance dispute, simulation may be joined with a claim restoring a reserved share.
Registration and third parties
Registration is decisive for real estate. The statement of claim must be entered in the Property Register, protecting the claimant.
A third party who acquires the property before the claim is registered may retain their rights if acting in good faith. A third party acquiring after registration loses the property if the claim succeeds. This reflects the principle that priority in time determines priority in right.
Practical steps
Where a sham transaction is suspected, prompt action is essential. The contract and related documents should be analysed, evidence including informal material collected, register entries and later transactions checked, the statement of claim registered and the correct combination of claims selected.
Common reasons for losing include relying only on witnesses, having no written evidence, registering the claim too late and underestimating third-party rights.
A sham property transaction is more than a formality that can simply be ignored. It creates real legal consequences until successfully challenged in court. Timely advice from a property lawyer and a sound litigation strategy are therefore essential to protecting ownership.

.webp)






