Clients often come to BSLC believing that they have valid insurance and that an insured event has clearly occurred, such as a road accident, fire or flood, yet they have received a formal refusal from their insurer. A typical example is a vehicle owner with comprehensive motor insurance who, after suffering damage, receives a letter stating that insufficient evidence has been provided or that the general terms and conditions have been breached. The immediate question is how to bring a court claim against the insurer and what prospects of success it has.
A refusal to pay does not automatically mean the insurer is right. The law strictly limits the grounds for refusing compensation, and the courts often protect insured persons where the refusal is merely formal or inadequately justified. However, without a sound legal strategy, evidence and timely action, many claims fail at an early stage.
Prompt advice from an insurance law specialist is essential because
- there are time limits for bringing a claim
- evidence must be collected and organised properly
- an incorrectly formulated claim may be dismissed.
BSLC assists with matters involving
- refusal to pay under comprehensive motor or third-party liability insurance
- claims for insurance compensation following a road accident
- court proceedings concerning property damage
- representation of an injured person against an insurance company
- direct claims against an insurer for damage caused by a third party ⚖️
When is an insurer's refusal lawful and when can it be challenged?
Refusals are governed by the Bulgarian Insurance Code, commonly abbreviated as KZ. The German Insurance Contract Act, or Versicherungsvertragsgesetz (VVG), provides a comparable framework, although Bulgarian legislation codifies the grounds for refusal in greater detail. The main provision is Article 408 of the Insurance Code, which exhaustively lists the circumstances in which an insurer may refuse payment.
The law permits refusal only in specified situations.
- The person entitled to payment intentionally caused the insured event.
- The policyholder intentionally caused the event for the benefit of a third party.
- A material breach of a contractual obligation caused the insured event.
- Another circumstance expressly provided for by law applies.
An insurer therefore cannot refuse payment arbitrarily or rely solely on internal rules or general terms that expand these statutory grounds.
The most common disputed refusals concern
- allegedly missing documents where no essential evidence is actually lacking
- unproven allegations of gross negligence
- reliance on clauses contrary to law
- formal breaches with no causal connection to the insured event.
Causation is the crucial legal issue. Even where the insured person has committed a breach, refusal is permissible only if that breach caused the insured event, as required by Article 408(1)(3) of the Insurance Code. This is one of the arguments most frequently used in litigation.
The position is even more favourable to injured persons under compulsory third-party liability insurance. The law permits a direct claim against the insurer, which cannot rely on every defence arising from its contract. This follows from Article 432 of the Insurance Code.
If the refusal does not clearly fall within a statutory ground or rests on formal reasoning alone, there is a substantial prospect of successfully challenging it in court.
How is a claim against an insurer filed and what must be proved?
A claim against an insurance company is a civil action governed by the general procedural rules, together with the specific rules of insurance law.
The first step is to identify the correct type of claim.
- A claim for payment of insurance compensation
- A direct claim by an injured person under third-party liability insurance
- A claim for default interest
A claim must first have been submitted to the insurer, because this forms part of the factual requirements for the right to arise.
In court, the claimant, whether the insured person or the injured party, must prove several main elements.
- A valid insurance contract exists.
- An insured event occurred.
- The amount of damage is established.
- There is a causal connection between the event and the damage.
The insurer, in turn, bears the burden of proving its grounds for refusal. This is a significant procedural advantage for the claimant.
Important evidence includes
- the insurance policy and general terms
- the notification of damage
- expert assessments, including vehicle engineering or medical reports
- road accident reports or other official documents
- correspondence with the insurer.
The outcome very often depends on a court-appointed expert report. After a road accident, for example, a vehicle engineering expert may establish how the accident occurred and what caused the damage.
Underestimating the importance of properly formulating the claim is a serious mistake. An incorrect amount or legal basis may result in partial or complete dismissal.
Before proceedings begin, it is sensible to obtain a professional assessment through a consultation with a lawyer. Not every instance of damage automatically leads to a successful claim.
When is interest awarded and what amounts can actually be recovered?
One of the most frequently overlooked issues in insurance litigation is the amount recoverable in addition to the damage itself.
The insurer owes not only the principal sum, meaning the compensation, but also statutory default interest. This follows from the general rules of the Bulgarian Obligations and Contracts Act. A comparable regime exists in the French Civil Code concerning intérêts moratoires.
Interest begins to accrue when the insurer falls into delay. In insurance relationships, this is usually
- after the statutory period for deciding the claim has expired, or
- after all required documents have been submitted.
A prolonged refusal or delay can therefore lead to a considerable interest claim, particularly where the damage is substantial.
The court may also award
- court costs, including the state fee and expert expenses
- lawyers' fees
- additional damages in certain cases.
Insurers often offer a lower out-of-court settlement precisely to avoid the accumulation of interest and costs.
Where a case is conducted properly, the final amount can be significantly higher than the initial offer.
Before starting proceedings, it is useful to calculate the likely costs and potential benefit. Tools such as the lawyers' fees calculator can help outline the financial implications of the dispute.
A dispute with an insurer is not merely an administrative exercise. It is a full court process in which every mistake, from the initial claim to the evidence presented in court, directly affects the outcome. Effective insurance representation requires a strategy, experience and knowledge of the relevant case law.

.webp)






