A client recently contacted BSLC after buying an apartment in Sofia. At first sight, it was a fully renovated, “luxury” property. A few months later, however, the client received a letter from the municipality. Part of the apartment had been altered without a building permit, incorporated common areas and was subject to removal. Alongside the cost of restoring the property, the client discovered that they also faced administrative liability as its owner.
Cases of this kind are not unusual. Unlawful alterations may appear to be a minor problem, but they create serious legal and financial risks for a buyer. The question is not simply whether the work is lawful. It is also what rights the buyer has against the seller and how those rights can be protected effectively.
BSLC assists clients in situations involving
- the purchase of a property with unlawful alterations
- litigation concerning unlawful construction
- claims against a property seller for latent defects
- the defence of property buyers facing administrative sanctions
- legal advice before a property transaction ⚖️
What are unlawful alterations and what consequences do they have for the buyer?
Alterations are governed by the Bulgarian Spatial Development Act, commonly abbreviated as ZUT. This is Bulgaria's principal legislation regulating construction. It is comparable to building regulations regimes in common law systems, but involves considerably stricter administrative control.
Under paragraph 5, item 38 of the Additional Provisions of the Spatial Development Act, “construction works” also include alterations. Even internal changes, such as adding partitions, enclosing balconies or creating openings, may therefore fall within the Act.
The case law is clear on the following points.
- Partitioning common areas and incorporating them into an apartment constitutes construction work in the form of an alteration and requires authorisation.
- The absence of a building permit makes the relevant work unlawful.
Where alterations have been carried out without the necessary construction documents, including a building permit and an approved design, they constitute unlawful construction under Article 225(2) of the Spatial Development Act.
The consequences are serious.
- A removal order may be issued under Article 225(1).
- The property may have to be restored to its original condition.
- Administrative sanctions may be imposed.
- Future sales or mortgages may be restricted.
Of particular significance is that, on acquiring the property, the buyer becomes a “developer” within the meaning of Article 161(1) of the Spatial Development Act, even if they did not carry out the work. This was confirmed in Judgment No. 2324 of 19.02.2013 of the Supreme Administrative Court in administrative case No. 10337/2012, in which the court held that the buyer also acquires that status.
In practice, this means that the new owner will be the addressee of the administrative measures and will bear the burden of removing the unlawful alterations.
Can the buyer hold the seller liable?
Yes. This is a key means of protecting the buyer.
The relationship between seller and buyer is governed by the Bulgarian Obligations and Contracts Act, commonly abbreviated as ZZD. It provides the contractual framework familiar in continental legal systems.
Unlawful alterations to a property are usually classified as a latent defect.
Under Article 193(1) of the Obligations and Contracts Act, the seller is liable where the property sold has defects that
- substantially reduce its value, or
- make it unsuitable for its usual or agreed purpose.
Unlawful alterations often satisfy both criteria.
- They reduce the value of the property because of the risks involved.
- They create a risk of removal or sanctions.
The buyer's rights include
- seeking rescission of the contract under Article 195(1) of the Obligations and Contracts Act
- a reduction in the price
- compensation for damage.
In practice, the most common claims concern
- compensation for the costs of legalisation or removal
- repayment of part of the price
- a combination of claims.
A central issue is whether the defect was latent. If the seller knew about the unlawful alterations and failed to disclose them, their liability is considerably greater.
Common mistakes include
- failing to check the construction documents
- relying on verbal assurances
- omitting warranties from the notarial deed.
Even if the notarial deed states that the buyer accepts the property in its existing condition, this does not release the seller from liability for latent defects that were not known to the buyer.
A preliminary assessment of the prospects of a particular claim can be obtained through a consultation with a lawyer.
What practical steps can protect a buyer who discovers unlawful alterations?
If unlawful alterations are discovered after the purchase, the response should be prompt and carefully planned. Delay may lead to missed deadlines or increased liability.
The main steps are set out below.
1. Check the legal status of the work
- Is there a building permit?
- Is there an approved design?
- Does the work qualify as “tolerated construction”?
The case law recognises that not every unlawful construction must be removed. It may qualify as tolerated construction if it was permissible under the earlier rules.
2. Assess the administrative risk
- Have proceedings under Article 225 of the Spatial Development Act begun?
- Who is the addressee of the order?
- Can the order be appealed?
The owner must participate in the removal proceedings and will bear their consequences.
3. Gather evidence against the seller
- Property advertisements, correspondence and witnesses
- Expert assessments
- Construction documents
4. Bring a claim
Depending on the circumstances, the appropriate action may be
- a claim for damages
- a claim for a price reduction
- a claim to rescind the transaction.
These claims fall within civil law and property disputes.
5. Pursue a defence in the administrative proceedings at the same time
- Appeal the removal order.
- Apply for legalisation, if this is permitted.
- Enter into discussions with the municipality.
One practical risk is often underestimated. Even if the buyer succeeds against the seller, the buyer must still comply with the administrative obligations, such as removal. The claim compensates for damage but does not replace the obligation owed to the state.
Buying a property with unlawful alterations is a typical example of the interaction between construction law and civil law. Without timely legal advice, both the financial and administrative risks remain with the buyer.

.webp)






