At BSLC, clients often contact us after paying a deposit towards a property purchase that never went ahead. A common scenario involves a buyer signing a preliminary contract and paying a sum usually described as a deposit, only for the seller to withdraw or undisclosed encumbrances to emerge. In other cases, the buyer withdraws, perhaps because a bank refuses financing. The key question is then whether the deposit must be returned.
This is more than a practical question. Its legal answer depends on how the payment was agreed and why the transaction failed. The distinction between an ordinary deposit and earnest money is often overlooked, yet it determines whether the payer can recover the sum, claim twice its amount or lose it altogether.
Timely advice from a property lawyer is crucial because a poorly drafted contract can cause substantial financial losses or a lengthy dispute over the transaction.
BSLC can assist with the following matters.
- Recovering a contractual deposit and preparing a claim for its repayment.
- Protecting your interests when a property purchase is abandoned.
- Reviewing preliminary contracts and earnest money clauses.
- Representing you in litigation concerning a deposit.
- Protecting a property buyer when the other party fails to perform.
When does a deposit qualify as earnest money, and why does this matter?
The Bulgarian word “kaparo”, commonly used for a deposit, has no separate statutory definition. In practice it is often equated with “zadatak”, or earnest money, which is expressly regulated by the Bulgarian Obligations and Contracts Act. The closest common law analogue is an earnest money deposit.
Under Article 93(1) of the Act, earnest money provides evidence that a contract has been concluded and security for its performance. The payment therefore serves two purposes.
- It confirms that the parties have reached agreement.
- It secures the performance of their obligations.
Crucially, not every payment described as a deposit automatically qualifies as earnest money. That effect must be expressly agreed or clearly follow from the contract.
Without such an agreement, the sum is generally treated as an advance payment. The consequences differ considerably.
- An advance must be returned when its legal basis ceases to exist.
- Earnest money may be retained or become repayable in double its amount.
In a consultation with a civil lawyer, the first question is therefore how the clause is actually worded.
Common mistakes include using the word “deposit” without defining its legal function, failing to distinguish earnest money from an advance and inserting contradictory clauses in the preliminary contract. These omissions cause serious difficulties when a property contract dispute arises.
When must the deposit or earnest money be returned?
The answer depends entirely on why the transaction failed and which party failed to perform. Article 93(2) of the Obligations and Contracts Act addresses three principal situations.
1. The party that paid the earnest money is responsible for the failure to perform
In this situation, the other party retains the earnest money. For example, the buyer withdraws without a valid reason or fails to secure financing despite undertaking to do so. The seller is then entitled to retain the payment. This is the most common situation when a buyer abandons a property purchase.
2. The party that received the earnest money is responsible for the failure to perform
The earnest money is then returned in double its amount. This may happen when the seller withdraws, the property has undisclosed encumbrances or the seller cannot transfer ownership. In those circumstances, the buyer is entitled to twice the deposit, rather than simply its repayment, as a form of compensation.
3. The contract is terminated by agreement or for reasons beyond the parties’ control
The earnest money is then returned. Examples include a bank refusing a loan where no express clause governs the matter, force majeure and objective impossibility of completing the transaction.
A specific financing clause can change the outcome. If the parties have agreed that the earnest money will not be returned if a loan is refused, that clause will apply. In the absence of such an agreement, the buyer may claim repayment.
How can you protect your rights in a dispute about repayment?
If the parties cannot agree, the dispute proceeds to court. A claim is brought for repayment of the deposit or payment of twice the earnest money.
The usual legal basis is Article 93 of the Obligations and Contracts Act for earnest money, or Article 55(1) of the Act concerning unjust enrichment where the payment was an advance.
Before proceedings begin, the preliminary contract, the parties’ correspondence, the reason for non-performance and the question of fault must all be carefully examined. These are the circumstances the court will investigate in a property transaction dispute.
The practical steps are to send a written demand for voluntary repayment, collect the contract and payment records, obtain legal advice and assess the prospects, and bring proceedings if repayment is refused.
Additional compensation may also be claimed where the damage exceeds the earnest money, in accordance with the general rules of the Obligations and Contracts Act.
Frequent risks include the absence of a written contract, unclear clauses, unsupported oral arrangements and incorrectly classifying the payment. In such cases, the court often finds that the sum was an ordinary payment rather than earnest money, which changes the outcome.
When a dispute arises, a consultation with a contract lawyer is advisable, particularly where substantial sums or complex property relationships are involved. The legal fees calculator can provide an initial indication of costs.
There is no universal answer to when a deposit must be returned. The contract, the parties’ conduct and the reason for non-performance all matter. Structuring the transaction properly from the outset is therefore the strongest protection for a property buyer.

.webp)






